Do you want to see how Yoast SEO stacks up against All in One SEO?
Both of these tools assist you in optimizing your website for search engines and social media platforms. The two most popular WordPress SEO plugins on the market are Yoast SEO and All in One SEO for WordPress.
We’ll compare Yoast SEO and All in One SEO in this article to help you decide which is the best WordPress SEO plugin.
About the Contestants
Both the All in One SEO for WordPress and the Yoast SEO plugins have large user bases and are among the most popular and widely used WordPress plugins ever.
Michael Torbert and Steve Mortiboy founded All in One SEO for WordPress in 2007. It has since amassed a large user base and has become one of the most popular WordPress plugins of all time.
Yoast SEO began in 2010 as WordPress SEO by Yoast. With consistent and ongoing improvements to the plugin, it quickly surpassed All in One SEO as a major competitor. Joost de Valk was the one who came up with the idea.
Both of these plugins are excellent and provide all of the essential features you’ll need to get the most out of your WordPress site’s SEO.
After that, let’s look at Yoast SEO vs. All in One SEO to see which one is the best WordPress SEO plugin.
Our comparison has been divided into the following sections:
- Installation and Configuration
- SEO Tasks on a Day-to-Day Basis
- Sitemaps and Indexing
- Support for Schema.org and Rich Snippets
- SEO Help for Ecommerce
- Additional SEO Instruments
- Comparison of Prices
- Conclusion: Which is better: Yoast SEO or All in One SEO?
Note: Both plugins have limited free versions, but for a more thorough comparison, we’ll compare their premium versions.
Yoast vs. AIOSEO: Setup and Installation
Search engine optimization is a specialized field, and learning and successfully applying it to websites takes time.
A WordPress SEO plugin should make it easier for complete beginners to implement basic SEO concepts with minimal effort.
Let’s compare and contrast these two plugins when it comes to installing and configuring basic SEO settings on WordPress sites.
Yoast SEO – Setup and Installation
See our step-by-step guide to installing a WordPress plugin for more information. The Yoast SEO plugin must first be installed and activated.
Users can access the configuration wizard under the Dashboard tab after activation by going to SEO » General.
This will launch a wizard that will guide you through the setup process step by step. This enables newcomers to get up and running quickly without being overwhelmed by jargon and options.
Yoast SEO is a powerful plugin with numerous settings that you must go over one by one. We’ve put together a guide on how to install and configure the Yoast SEO plugin in WordPress to make things easier for you.
Yoast SEO’s settings section is neatly divided into pages, with different tabs for different settings on each page.
This makes it simple for users to find a setting they want.
Simply click the purple question mark at the bottom of the page to expand the support documentation. On all pages of the Yoast SEO settings, there is on-screen help.
Beginners can easily set up Yoast SEO on their WordPress site thanks to well-organized settings, a configuration wizard for beginners, and on-screen help options.
Installation and Setup for All-in-One SEO
See our step-by-step guide to installing a WordPress plugin for more information. The All in One SEO for WordPress plugin must first be installed and activated.
The plugin will automatically launch the setup wizard after activation.
To continue, simply click the Let’s Get Started button.
Yoast SEO’s setup wizard has fewer steps than this one. Despite the fact that they have similar options, All in One SEO makes them easier to understand for beginners.
We have a step-by-step guide that walks you through the entire wizard on how to properly set up All in One SEO.
After completing the wizard, go to the All in One SEO » General Settings page to access plugin settings.
For example, Search Appearance, Sitemaps, and Redirects, among other things. There are several sections on the General Settings page. Then, in the left column, there are different pages for various features under the General Settings menu.
Each option has a help icon next to it. A help icon is also located at the top of the page, which can be used to get more information. When you click on the icon, a brief description of the feature appears.
Beginners will have an easier time understanding what they are doing as a result of this. Most websites would be ready to start working on their website and using All in One SEO for day-to-day tasks after just completing the wizard.
All in One SEO for WordPress is the winner.
Both plugins have a lot of features, and they try to make things as simple as possible for users to get started. With their set up wizard, we believe All in One SEO does a slightly better job than Yoast SEO.
SEO Tasks on a Daily Basis – Yoast SEO vs. All-in-One SEO
This means you’ll be using your SEO plugin to optimize your content for search engines on a regular basis. Each new post or page you add has its own SEO score, so SEO is a continuous process.
See our guide on how to optimize your WordPress blog posts for SEO for more information.
Let’s take a look at how our contenders fare when it comes to handling day-to-day SEO tasks on your WordPress site.
Yoast SEO’s Day-to-Day SEO Tasks
You can see it by hovering your mouse over the plugin icon in the top right corner. Yoast SEO includes a content analysis tool that will assist you in optimizing each post or page on your website.
Yoast SEO meta box with snippet preview, focus keyword field, and content analysis is located just below the post editor.
Yoast SEO uses your post title as the title and the excerpt as the description by default, but you can change it by clicking on it. The Google Preview shows how the title and description of your site will appear in search results.
When you enter the focus keyword in Yoast SEO, the plugin will analyze your content for that keyword.
The results are displayed in the content analysis section, where Yoast SEO will offer suggestions on how to improve the SEO score of your post.
You can also change the article’s schema markup settings by switching to the Schema tab.
The social tab is the last tab on the menu. This is where you can customize your Twitter card and set an article image for Facebook.
Yoast SEO will use your main SEO title and description in the open graph meta tags, so you can skip the description and title bank.
All in One SEO’s Day-to-Day SEO Tasks
Unlike Yoast SEO, All in One SEO gives your content a real score. It’s known as the TruSEO score, and it provides a more actionable approach to optimizing your content.
The content analysis panel will expand when you click on it. You’ll see the All in One SEO button in the top right corner of the edit screen, along with your SEO score for that post or page. Simply make a change to the post or page you want to optimize.
When you click on a keyword, it expands, and you can see what actions you can take to improve your score. Aside from that, each of your focus keywords will have a score assigned to it.
Each content type’s AIOSEO settings are located below the post editor. Your focus key, title, and description can all be added here.
Dynamic Tags are one of the most useful features you’ll notice. These tags can be used to add dynamic elements to your SEO title and descriptions, such as the current category, year, month, and more.
For example, if your SEO title is ‘Best Coffee Shops in NYC (2021),’ you can use the current year tag, which will change to 2022 the following year.
This can help you get more traffic and improve your SEO rankings by increasing your click-through rate in search results.
You can also go to the Social tab in All in One SEO and add a Facebook or Twitter image.
If necessary, the plugin also allows you to change the Schema type of a single post.
It gives you an overall score for the SEO settings on your site. A Site Analysis feature is also included in All in One SEO. You can also use the Competitor Analysis tool to compare your site to competitors.
All in One SEO is the winner.
Both plugins make it simple to change SEO settings for individual posts. With a TruSEO score and a Focus Key score, All in One SEO provides a more actionable plan. It also has an advantage over Yoast SEO because of dynamic tags in the title and description.
All in One SEO vs Yoast SEO: Indexing and Sitemaps
An SEO plugin’s primary function is to assist search engines in discovering more of your content.
This is accomplished through the creation of sitemaps, the use of webmaster tools, the monitoring of your site’s SEO, and other methods.
Let’s take a look at how Yoast SEO and All in One SEO approach this topic.
Yoast SEO Indexing and Sitemaps
It does not have a dedicated page to view or manage your XML sitemaps to keep things simple. Yoast SEO creates XML sitemaps for all of your post types automatically.
However, you can enable or disable XML sitemaps by going to SEO » General and selecting the ‘Features’ tab.
From the plugin’s settings, you don’t have the option to include or exclude post types from your XML sitemap.
Yoast also makes it simple to verify your website with webmaster tools such as Google Search Console, Bing Webmaster Tools, Baidu, and Yandex.
This makes it possible for videos and news websites to appear in Google News and video search results. The Video and News sitemap extensions are also available to Yoast SEO premium subscribers to install and activate.
All-in-One SEO: Indexing and Sitemaps
All in One SEO also creates XML sitemaps for your WordPress site automatically. Unlike Yoast SEO, it has a dedicated settings page under All in One SEO » Sitemaps where you can easily manage your XML sitemap.
Different settings for managing your XML sitemaps can be found by scrolling down. You have the option of including specific post types and taxonomies in your sitemaps.
You can also add any custom page to your sitemap with AIOSEO. This is useful if you’re using a custom landing page that wasn’t built with WordPress.
As with Yoast, you can enable Video and News sitemaps as extensions. Additionally, AIOSEO includes an RSS sitemap feature.
All in One SEO is the winner.
All in One SEO, on the other hand, gives you a lot more control over your XML sitemaps. Both plugins have great XML sitemap capabilities.
Support for Schema.org – Yoast SEO vs. All in One SEO
Schema markup is a type of HTML code that you can use on your website to tell search engines more about the information contained in your content.
You can specify whether the content is a recipe, a blog post, or a product page, for example. Rich snippets can now be displayed in search results thanks to this.
Let’s see how All in One SEO and Yoast SEO compare in this regard.
Support for Schemas – Yoast SEO
Yoast SEO adds schema metadata to your WordPress posts and pages automatically. Visit the SEO » Search Appearance page to see the default settings.
You can then enter a name and a logo in the fields below. Scroll down to the section on Knowledge Graphs and Schema.org. You can choose whether your website is for an individual or an organization from this menu.
Switch to the Content Types tab to see more schema options. You’ll find the default Schema settings for your content types if you scroll down to the bottom of the page.
Individual posts and pages can also have their scheme types changed. Simply edit the content and switch to the Schema tab in the Yoast SEO metabox.
To provide more detailed information about your business, you can also install the Yoast Local SEO extension.
Support for Schemas – All-in-One SEO
It’s accessible from the All in One SEO » Search Appearance page. Similarly, All in One SEO has a default section for schema.org settings that apply to the entire site.
You can provide your company or individual’s name, logo, phone number, and contact type (sales, support, etc.) from here.
You can also alter the default Schema settings for each of your content types.
You can also customize schema settings for each post and page individually. Simply scroll down to the Schema tab under AIOSEO settings on the post edit screen.
The plugin also includes a local SEO extension to aid in the optimization of your site for local search results.
Tie for first place
With full schema.org support, both plugins are neck and neck. All in One SEO does a slightly better job of drawing attention to those options.
Support for Ecommerce – Yoast SEO vs. All in One SEO
This emphasizes the importance of eCommerce SEO for your company. If you run an online store, organic traffic results in direct sales for your company.
Let’s take a look at how both plugins perform for eCommerce websites, regardless of whether they use WooCommerce or another eCommerce plugin.
Support for Ecommerce – Yoast SEO
Yoast SEO comes pre-installed with support for eCommerce sites. Yoast SEO has a separate Yoast WooCommerce SEO plugin for websites that use WooCommerce.
You can add a product title and description by default, just like you can for posts and pages. Yoast SEO also generates an XML sitemap for your store’s product categories.
You will be able to provide additional data for product pages after installing WooCommerce SEO.
Support for Ecommerce – All-in-One SEO
All in One SEO for WordPress comes pre-installed with more robust eCommerce support. Without you having to do anything, it correctly identifies a product as Product in schema markup as soon as you add it.
It also enables you to add more eCommerce schema data, which aids in the expansion of your store. You can change the schema markup for each product and add more rich details like brand, colors, and manufacturer.
All in One SEO also creates XML sitemaps for your products and product categories automatically.
If you’re using a simple order form rather than WooCommerce or a shopping cart plugin but still want to optimize that page as a product, All in One SEO can help. Simply edit the page and change the schema type to Product in the AIOSEO settings.
All in One SEO is the winner.
It’s a lot easier with All in One SEO, which includes the ability to optimize product pages without having to install an eCommerce plugin, making it better suited for online stores. Yoast offers an extension that adds eCommerce support.
Additional Tools – Yoast SEO vs. All in One SEO
That’s why, in addition to meta tags, both of these plugins include additional tools and features. On-page SEO is a multi-step procedure.
These features exist to provide you with a true all-in-one solution, removing the need to install multiple SEO plugins.
Additional Yoast SEO Tools
These are some of the tools available: Yoast SEO has a long list of features that cover almost every aspect of on-site optimization.
- Navigation by Breadcrumb
- Meta Tags for Open Graph
- Using Google Webmaster Tools to Import Data
- Editors for robots.txt and.htaccess are built-in.
- Data on SEO can be imported and exported.
- Manager of Redirects
Additional Tools for All-in-One SEO
All in One SEO has the same set of features as All in One SEO, but it has a slightly better user interface.
- Navigation using the breadcrumbs
- Meta Tags for Open Graph
- Editor for robots.txt and.htaccess
- SEO Data Import and Export
- Manager of Redirects
Tie for first place
All in One SEO has a nice interface, but when it comes to functionality, it’s a tie. Both plugins provide a similar set of extra tools and features.
Yoast SEO vs. All in One SEO Pricing
Both plugins have limited free versions, but you’ll need to upgrade to the paid version to get access to all of their features. For many users, price is an important consideration.
Both plugins have paid or premium versions that include priority support and regular updates.
Let’s look at the pricing of both of our competitors.
Yoast SEO charges a monthly fee.
Yoast SEO premium is $89 for a single site license, and the price increases as you add more sites. Each extension, such as WooCommerce SEO, Local SEO, News SEO, and Video SEO, is $69 for a single site.
For each website you want to use it on, you’ll need to purchase additional subscriptions. You can also purchase a $199/year subscription plan that includes all extensions but can only be used on one website.
The cost of all-in-one SEO
The free version of All in One SEO has limited support and features.
Upgrade to a paid plan for priority support, which starts at $49.50 for a single site with one year of support and updates.
At $199.50, their best value plan includes all add-ons and features for up to 10 sites.
All in One SEO is the winner.
The pricing is very similar if you only have one website. However, all Yoast subscriptions are restricted to a single website. All in One SEO’s Pro plan, on the other hand, includes up to 10 websites, making it a much better deal.
Conclusion: Which is better: Yoast SEO or All in One SEO?
Because both All in One SEO and Yoast SEO are excellent plugins, any comparison between the two must be thorough.
All in One SEO, on the other hand, wins in terms of ease of use, improved user experience, and more control over various features.
When it comes to eCommerce SEO, eCommerce schema support, and local SEO, All in One SEO is the best.
All in One SEO’s on-site SEO audit and TruSEO score features provide beginners with a step-by-step plan for improving their content and improving their SEO.
And if you have multiple websites, All in One SEO will save you a lot of money.
We hope this Yoast SEO vs. All in One SEO comparison helped you choose the best WordPress SEO plugin for your site. You might also be interested in our list of the 9 best WordPress SEO plugins and tools to use, as well as our guide to choosing the best WordPress hosting.
Please subscribe to our YouTube Channel for WordPress video tutorials if you enjoyed this article. You can also find us on social media sites such as Twitter and Facebook.
Step-by-Step Instructions for Starting Your Own Podcast
How to Fix the WordPress Error Establishing a Database Connection
Beginner’s Guide to Installing Google Analytics in WordPress
How to Transfer Your Blog from WordPress.com to WordPress.org Correctly
Editorial Staff Information
Over 1.3 million readers around the world rely on it. WPBeginner’s Editorial Staff is a group of WordPress experts led by Syed Balkhi.
For years, I’ve used both interchangeably for various sites. I just wanted to express my gratitude for the article. This time, I decided to figure out why they’re different, and I appreciate your clarity in comparing the two.
We’re glad you found our comparison to be useful.
All-in-one SEO is still the best option.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
In Free Yoast, there is no option to noindex paginated pages. However, All in One SEO allows you to do so.
Noindex Tags is not an option in Yoast, but it is available in All in One SEO.
This article has been extremely beneficial to me. Thank you so much for sharing this, guys.
We hope you found our article useful.
We had to switch from Yoast SEO to All In One SEO Pack because Yoast’s free version only allows for one keyword per post/page, whereas All In One SEO Pack allows for many.
Thank you for taking the time to express yourself.
I completely switched to Allin1 and must say that it is the best. I’ve been using both plugins, but Yoast seemed to be the better option until it started causing issues with content display.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts on both plugins.
I’d like to see a comparison of the most recent SEO plugins.
Thank you for suggesting an article for publication.
Will I have to edit all of my posts, especially the keywords I used in yoast, if I switch to all-in-one seo?
For the answer to that, you should contact all in one’s support for the specifics of what is transferred when you swap plugins.
You don’t have to be an SEO expert to figure out that YOAST will cause your Google ranking to plummet.
I’m not familiar with Yoast, but I tried working on my page professionally and calmly in order to get that green dot, but at the end of the day, I’m on Google’s 5th page, despite the fact that not using the plugin ranks me higher than using it. I’ve tried it on six different websites with no luck.
Yoast is only for SEO professionals, such as those who run this site, because they know how to write blog posts, use keywords, and so on. Believe me when I say that I found them on Google’s first page #1. It’s as if it’s Google’s paid content.
My advice is to avoid attempting if you are not an SEO professional… and to rank higher in Google naturally, avoid using these fancy heavy CSS design sites.
Google favors a simple, light-weight site with an unattractive user interface.
They did an excellent job of including a setup wizard, allowing even the most inexperienced users to set up their site for proper SEO. I’m not sure what happened to your site, but Yoast is the most complete WordPress SEO plugin.
If you want to get the most out of SEO, you’ll need to use a good SEO plugin.
Nice write-up… I believe I prefer All in on e to yoast because any misconfiguration in yoast will result in your search engine being disabled. Wow!
I’ve tried SEO frameworks and new plugins, but I’m still using Yoast because there’s a plugin that removes and strips down all the Yoast banners and links. For me, this is the ideal combination.
Well, I read this article in the hopes of deciding between Yoast and AIOSEO, but I’m even more perplexed than before.
Yes, I agree! As usual, I was defeated.
Thank you for your informative review!
I’ve noticed that Yoast offers free SEO tools for categories, whereas All-in-One only offers them in the Pro version.
Yoast also comes with some nice OG tags right out of the box.
So, after a brief romance with All-in-One SEO, I decided to return to Yoast.
That’s something I’m missing. A redirect option is not available in either in one or Yoast.
Greetings, Marcin is a writer who lives in Poland.
My site’s ranking on Google, Bing, and Yahoo has significantly improved since I started using AIOSEO. Thanks to AIOSEO, search engines account for 18% of my daily visitors. To begin with, Yoast configuration is a nightmare; any mistake you make will severely hurt your ranking, and post titles and meta tags are always problematic.
Yoast will constantly, and I mean constantly, screw up your titles. Despite AIOSEO never having this problem, Joost will blame it on Google.
Just my one-hundredth of a penny. All of the readability and yoast scoring will do more harm than good. I was using a free version of AIOS at the time and switched to yoast. Even the Google snippet would be ineffective. Regrettably, my position on the front page has slipped. My rank has risen since I returned to AIOS, and my Google snippet is perfect, with h1 and h2 tags working as intended. Okay, I’ve tried both of these SEO plugins, and Yoast is bloatware that will lower your Google rankings.
Hello, can I use both at the same time? Is this a problem?
Please choose the one you prefer and deactivate the others. Yes, it’s bad, and you could have serious SEO and performance issues as a result.
I made use of both.
It’s a fantastic plugin… Yoast SEO is what I’m using. Thank you for subscribing.
There’s a problem with Yoast, at least when using WPEngine as your hosting provider. It does something that sends links to the host that contain unsafe characters. If WPEngine notices enough of them, they will immediately block your IP.
As a result, I’ve lost two blog posts, as well as the work that went into editing them. I’m not sure if it’s a Yoast or a WPEngine issue, but it’s a problem!
I’m not sure if other hosts will have the same issue, but Yoast and WPEngine need to figure out how to fix it at the very least. Any plugin or hoster that allows me to enter a link that results in this type of lockout and data loss is a bad thing.
Yoast Support is aware of the problem and has informed me that it is beyond their control and that I should contact my site’s host. This issue only occurs when Yoast is turned on. Our site, on the other hand, is hosted by InMotionHosting, who have thoroughly investigated the problem and determined that it is caused by Yoast. We are disconnected and locked out of the site for 10-15 minutes while editing a post. My company’s WordPress site is experiencing a similar problem. Any assistance is greatly appreciated!
YOAST SEO was also a favorite of mine. Thank you for providing such an open and honest review! Oh my goodness!!
This is an excellent article.
Please help. 1. Premium WordPress SEO 3. SEO Plugin for WooCommerce 2. WordPress’s Local SEO I’d like some technical advice on whether installing the following three YOAST Plugins in my eCommerce site is a good idea:
For my blog, I’ll use the Yoast SEO plugin. Thank you for the wonderful review.
How can a newbie blogger with a wordpress website get premium SEO?
If you are a beginner, you can use a free service, but it is recommended that you use the PRO features. Hello…
The analogy is very clear. This is a good one… It’s fantastic and can help you improve your overall score. Yoast SEO is something I would recommend to everyone.
Sir, could you please assist me? I’m still perplexed!
I’m not a fan of Yoast yet, but if I can’t find another tool/plugin for my WordPress website, I may have to adapt. I like All in One, but please correct me if I’m wrong, but it appears to be only for blogs? Any suggestions or advice would be greatly appreciated. We do blogs as well, but I was specifically looking for a tool for our client websites.
It collides with woocommerce, resulting in errors that cause the system to crash. When it comes to PHP 7, Yoast SEO is completely useless!
I’ll have to say my goodbyes and move on at that point. When I try to contact support, I’m told that woocommerce is the issue.
So, if you have a woocommerce store and PHP 7, I do not recommend installing the Yoast SEO plugin.
was enjoyable for a while Yoast, farewell…
great, okay I believe this is why I stopped using it in the first place, but I’m going to give it another shot.
But, for a beginner and novice like myself, I believe AiO should be the first choice, or is there another option at this level? Thank you so much for this post; it is extremely informative and beneficial to both myself and others. Thank you very much.
I’m intrigued by SEOPressor; it appears to be quite good, though I don’t believe the prices page, based on the features it offers and those offered by competitors.
Can you do a review with SEOPressor and the two plugins mentioned above, wpbeginner?
Right now, both are loaded, and I’m getting the following message: This is an excellent article. I’m finally attacking the web with a sincere desire to make money online, so I’m learning everything there is to know about WordPress (which is a DEMON! ), SEO/online marketing (which is a lesser demon, but still…), and various other aspects of building a viable online presence. I’m new to SEO, though I’ve been aware of it for a while.
Would you like the to be turned off? The imported plugin’s old data was successfully deleted.” “The data from All in One SEO was successfully imported. Would you like to install our after you’ve enabled Google Analytics in All in One SEO?
Now it’s a toss-up, but I believe everyone is siding with Yeost, so I’m siding with him. So I looked for comparisons and came across this.
You’ll never get a green “good” score unless you use bizarre sentence structure and dumb down your content for morons. I’ve been using Yoast for a few years and enjoy it, but their new “readability” scoring is driving me crazy.
When Google makes updates, the content analysis calculator is frequently inaccurate as well. Before there was a calculator (ya know, how everyone used to do it? ), people should have known to sprinkle key phrases in the title, description, and content.
Also, AiO beats Yoast when it comes to mass edits, because AiO does it from the pages/posts page (where you can view as many as you want in the options of that administration page) vs. Yoast’s mass editor tool, which only allows like 10 pages to be shown at a time?
Thank you for the excellent article, Syed. I use both on different websites, and while Yeost is probably more comprehensive in general, I find All in One to be easier to use and take less time.
So, for less zealous users and newbies, I’d recommend All in One.
David is a man of many talents.
Why don’t we start with a non-paying option for students and low-income communities? The cost of web hosting is excessive!
I spend £50 per year to host ten websites. The cost of hosting a website is extremely low.
Your comment has nothing to do with the article.
Could you tell me which hosting company you use for your 10 sites?
Especially in the advanced menu’s social settings, sometimes when I share an article on Facebook, the image preview does not appear in a large picture, resulting in my article having little impact on the reader. This is an excellent comparison analysis; after reading this, I’ve realized that there are some Yoast SEO features that I’ve never used before. I now combine the All in One SEO Pack and Yoast SEO plugins. For content analysis, use Yoast SEO, and for meta description and keyword generation, use All in One SEO.
Hello, can I use both at the same time?
No, you cannot use both at the same time.
Should the ability to change how your image behaves on Facebook and Twitter be a big plus in All in One SEO? Is there a similar option (or addon) in the Yoast free or premium version?
This is a good question for someone looking for either of these things. For me, it does. I’d be interested in hearing your thoughts on this.
If I had to choose between Yoast and Allin1, I’d go with Yoast, but when you consider all of Yoast’s advanced capability upgrades, I believe SEOPressor is a better value. After testing a number of SEO plugins, I believe SEOPressor is the best option. Their new design and expanded functionality demonstrate that this is the far superior plugin! Neither of them!
SEOPressor, in my opinion, is a joke. They only accept ClinkBank for payments, and their customer service is terrible.